Goatriders of the Apocalypse

2010 Player Preview: Carlos Marmol

Behold, the destruction or salvation of the 2010 Chicago Cubs.  Carlos Marmol is the key.  In a bullpen rife with weakness, with no other option available, Jim Hendry is putting all of his closer eggs into Marmol's basket.  Looking purely at his stuff, it is evident that Carlos is the right choice to make.  He is at times unhittable.  In 307.2 career innings of work, Marmol has surrendered a mere 195 hits.  That's freaking ridiculous.

But he is also at times unable to hit the strike zone.  His BB/9 ratio went up dramatically between 2008 and 2009 (from a respectable 4.2 per 9 innings to a terrifying 7.9 per 9 last year).  In other words, up until 2009 Marmol was effective, but last year he was effectively wild.  This is a risky scenario for a guy who's expected to end each game he pitches in.  There aren't many pitchers I can think of who had long, successful careers while walking 7.9 batters per 9 innings of work.

If Carlos is able to face down his pitching demons and regularly locate the strike zone, then I anticipate that he will have an outstanding season and the Cubs will be that much more likely to compete successfully.  But if he falls, so fall the Cubs.  There's just nobody else in the bullpen who can assume that role, and Jim Hendry is unlikely to pull a trade for anybody who can.

Get good deals on tickets to Cubs games through sponsor and MLB ticket broker
Coast to Coast Tickets!


The guy had a bad year because of the WBC and his awful performance. I'd be willing to bet that there was some arm trouble also. Marmol is a minor worry, but I think he'll be fine.

I hope you're right, but my

I hope you're right, but my inclination is to blame Lou's handling of him. If we remember back to 2008, there was a month-or-so period in which he was absolutely a disaster on the mound, and that stemmed from long-term overuse by Lou. It'll be harder to abuse him in a closer's position, but if the bullpen is particularly thin we may see back-to-back, multiple-inning outings from Marmol, the result of which may be a lack of control and effectiveness.

Chicago Tribune's Chicago's Best Blogs award