Goatriders of the Apocalypse

Is it time to forgive Sammy?

Growing up, my favorite Cub was Andre Dawson. He was an exciting player to watch, maybe because you knew that on any given day, his leg could come off at the knee. In the Hawk's final year as a Cub, there was another exciting outfielder on the team. Sammy Sosa. Mr. Sosa hustled, to be sure, and he hit the ball hard, but let's face it: he was never Andre Dawson.

He was never the Hawk for one simple reason: Andre was a team player. Sammy believed that you couldn't spell "team" without "me." Sammy was concerned with his massive homeruns, he was concerned with his stolen base totals, he was concerned with the amount of money he was making, and only after all that was he concerned about winning, if at all. But, while Sosa was playing for Chicago, he put up Nintendo numbers. Here, go and look: Sammy's career numbers.

This (possibly almost certainly steroid-fueled) monster averaged almost 61 homeruns and 149 RBI while batting .310 over a four year period. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that we will never, ever see production like that again for as long as we live. And he did it as a Cub.

I'm sure that we could all tell stories about some of the exciting homeruns he hit that we got to see. We could also commiserate about the slow decline which started in 2002, which reached its' sad ending in the last month of the 2004 season. Based on the selfish, absurd behavior he displayed at the end, it is very easy to agree that Sammy Sosa is no hero.

On the other hand, he quite possibly is one of the five best Cubs to ever play the game, although he'd get dropped off the list pretty quickly if attitude played a part in the decision making. But, Sammy really was the face of the team for more than half a decade. Granted, you could point out that "Sammy as the face of the team" is an excellent example of everything that's wrong with Cubs baseball, but the point remains. Sosa should have his number retired. As long as they don't outright bust him for steroid abuse, he should be a diplomat for baseball.

But no, to answer my own question, it is not yet time to forgive Sammy. There were a lot of reasons why the 2004 season collapsed into a massive pile of feces, but one of the biggest reasons was the offensive collapse of Sammy Sosa in September, followed by his outrageous antics during the last day of the season. As a fan who is still angrily waiting for a return to the World Series, I have to admit that I still feel bitter and betrayed whenever I think about how that otherwise exciting season ended.

Therefore, no, it is not time to forgive Sammy. This is the stage of the metaphorical breakup where the two sides should be sending each other bland EMails which say nothing of substance, where the two parties should be leaving messages on each other's answering machines that vaguely - but with hope - allude to a point in the future where they can be friends again.

But as far as Sammy Sosa the player should be remembered ... I think three words sum it up: exciting but selfish. You may disagree, but I think that that says it all.

Mike D.

I don't get that worked up in a lather for what Sosa did on the last day of '04 but, rather, by how sensitive he was to being moved down in the order earlier in that season. Granted, Dusty deserves some blame for not being man enough to just do it, but Sammy's ego really did complicate the issue.

Larry Walker gets dealt to the Tards, and Scott Rolen--who's in his prime--volunteers to move down in the order. In the same summer, getting an aging, slowed Sosa to agree to help the team by doing the same thing ended up wasting the better part of the crucial summer months.

The guy was an utter assbag. Exciting as hell at times but, in the end, he was just a fame-seeking jerk. Good riddance.

Chip Wesley

Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't Sosa the only Cub player that refused to talk to Gene Wojciechowski when he was writing Cubs Nation?

He wasn't listed as one of the 5 finalists for the Hometown Heroes, and I don't believe he should be. I can't honestly put him ahead of Ernie, Billy, Fergie, Ron or Ryne. If you wanna talk 6th man on the list, I'll take Mark Grace over Sosa.

Sloth

There's nothing for me to forgive him about. I never bought into his silly ass, even before he swole all up.

That having been said, for MLB or the Cubs or whoever put together that poll to leave him off of the top "five" is moronic. Put his ass out there, and let the fans decide.

kurt

An excellent point, Sloth. I suspect that there are still enough fans out there who detest Sosa. The man wouldn't have been voted through even if he HAD been on the list, and that would have been more telling than keeping him off the list to begin with.

Chip Wesley

From mlb.com:

"Nominees selected to appear on the ballot were chosen for their contributions to their franchise's history using the Hometown Heroes selection criteria of on-field performance, leadership quality and character value. The majority of nominees were selected by individual clubs."


Sorry folks, but Sammy is lacking in 2 of those three criteria. Simply hitting the crap out of the ball doesn't automatically get you to the top of the list.

Mike D.

Sloth,

Who do you leave off?

Banks and Jenkins are no-brainers, IMO. Because Sandberg was at an "up-the-middle" position, he should stay. Santo's been overlooked at third base nationally, but it's a more important position than left field, where Williams played, and Santo was a stud with the leater.

If you put Sammy on, you gotta take off the sweet singin' hitter from Whistler, Alabama. Can you live with that?

Jason R.

I wouls personally consider Jenkins the most questionable inclusion. With only 6+ years on the Cubs, does he reall belong with Santo, Williams, Sandberg, and Banks? Or, for that matter, Sammy?

I'm not sure who I would go with as my fifth, but I think it should be someone who was predominantly a Cub.

Chip Wesley

When you say 6+, do you mean 10? Because that's how many seasons Fergie had with the Cubs. I'd say that's more than enough to qualify. Not to mention his peak years were in Chicago, when he posted 6 consecutive 20-win seasons from 1967-72.

Chicago Tribune's Chicago's Best Blogs award